• Post published:

Is Edtech really improving outcomes for marginalised children?

We aimed to holistically understand the impact of EdTech on Black/Black heritage children. We wanted to do this in a relevant and useful way that brought, and uncovered skills and resources of the people we worked with.

Our project goals were to:

  1. Build community with people interested in understanding how Edtech is being used in our primary schools;
  2. Help develop community research skills in both quantitative and qualitative data collection and analysis in order to better understand what is going on;
  3. Shed light on what Edtech is being used in our schools, which companies are selling them and understand what they are doing with our children’s data;
  4. Understand the extent and impact of digital exclusion on children living in economically deprived areas.

Successes and challenges

As a community research project, we successfully recruited and had continued engagement with our research team of community researchers (CRs), data analysts and community organisers who were primarily of Black/Black heritage and all from marginalised communities. 

We investigated the use of EdTech across 90 schools in Birmingham’s most deprived wards. With training and support our CRs, analysed school websites for mentions and details of EdTech, reviewed schools’ equality impact assessments and collected insights from 99 individuals through interviews, a focus group and questionnaires. We hosted two community events reaching 69 primarily Black/Black heritage adults and overall directly engaged around 200 people. Researchers expressed high satisfaction with the interaction and support provided by DTBC and completed their assigned work. Event attendees gave positive feedback about the information we delivered that helped to shape our ‘Let’s do it together’ toolkit– designed to support parents and guardians to protect data about their children. This will benefit not just Black/Black heritage parents/ guardians, but all parents/ guardians based in England and Wales.

Our main challenge was around timing. We gathered a lot of interest and support from ordinary folks who squeezed this work into their busy lives. We stretched our resources to ensure that everyone we worked with could be supported to participate, but we recognised that this work had to be balanced alongside their other commitments. We chose to be flexible with our timings and prioritised care to individuals as the core element of our work. We are grateful to Open Society Foundation Foundations for providing us with the flexibility to extend our project and in providing funding that enabled us to collaborate with others in an equitable way. Other challenges in completing the research are detailed in our report “What if we took stewarding children’s data seriously?”.

Collaborators

BLAST provided us with valuable insight, which shaped our approach to community building and extended our reach

Defend Digital Me provided expertise in children’s rights and use of EdTech which supported our analysis of the findings and shaped our “Let’s do it together” toolkit

Community Researchers (CRs): Aké Achi, Sadia Aweis, Denise Amory-Reid, Ryan Campbell, Audrey Deane, Sabrina Fullerton, Joe Marson, Fartun Mohamed, Alima Rico and Abi Shervington. Provided data collection, analysis and support with project direction. 

Data analysts: Feyisara Akin-Bashiru⁩ and Gabriel Olabade (lead data analyst). Provided delivery and project management support for data collection and analysis. They supported the work of the CRs and inputted on project direction and scope. 

⁨Community Organisers: Sahdya Darr & Kiki Shervington (who additionally designed the engagement and events material). They facilitated community and stakeholder engagement, event organisation, project administration, CR support; and also supported project direction and management.

Dr Martin Glynn provided project support for community researchers with data storytelling for community engagement

AWO reviewed and provided feedback on the analysis framework we used in assessing the EdTech applications and platforms discovered in the course of delivering this project. 

Adrienne Williams, The Distributed AI Research Institute provided international expertise in the use of EdTech

Charlotte Bailey led on design and editing of the project report and co-ordinated illustrations and animation of the project and the DTBC website.

Alima Rico led on illustrations and design of elements within the “Let’s do it together” toolkit

Malikah Holder designer and creator of our EdTech animation explainer video

Florence Okoye led on web design and development.

DTBC Stewards

Ade Adewunmi, Dr Mwenza Blell, Tracey Gyateng, Anita Shervington, provided project direction, management and delivery.

Outputs

Project update blogs: