• Post published:

Data and Tech Use Within Employment & Enterprise Settings — A Primer

We ran roundtables in March 2021 connecting UK Black communities around Data, Tech and the following topics: Education, Crime & Justice, Employment & Enterprise, Health, and a final presentation.

The purpose of this blog was to provide a primer to participants attending a roundtable on the use of data and technology. It explains key terms used and provides relevant examples of how data and technology can negatively impact upon Black lives in the UK. Many of the points we raise apply to other marginalised communities too.

Topics in this toolkit

What are data and technology?

The terms data and technology are understood in a multitude of ways. A common definition of data is: a collection of curated information that can take the form of numbers, words, pictures. An example is the Companies House register — a database of registered UK companies containing details such as directors’ names and service addresses, company accounts, charges and other types of business activity. This register (which isn’t without its issues) is maintained by the government agency, Companies House.

For our purposes, we can broadly think of technology as the various digital tools and systems (sometimes further enabled by data and machine learning) that deliver or support specific tasks. Video conferencing tools like Zoom which are facilitating remote working, are a good example. Another example is the use of Artificial-Intelligence (AI) enabled software for everything from recruitment to employee ‘productivity’ tracking and staff retention.

How are data and technology used with regards to employment and enterprise?

Data and technology are undoubtedly useful aids for the smooth management of many activities related to employment and business. For example, they can help with supply chain management or to discover trends that can help businesses and government policy. However, the use of machine learning (which is powered by data and digital tech) can exacerbate existing discriminatory trends. Human biases- which are found in all datasets- are picked up by the algorithms as trends; these patterns shape future predictions. For example, when Amazon’s hiring algorithm ‘learned’ to associate successful hires with certain gender-correlated variables, it downgraded CVs from women. In other words, it reflected and sought to replicate the company’s past hiring patterns. Amazon discarded the algorithm.

However, other large multinational employers, like Unilever, are still using AI-enabled software to screen job applicants. The Information Commissioners Office, has rightly sounded the alarm about the privacy, bias and discrimination risks. But algorithms are affecting other aspects of work too. For example, UK Amazon warehouse workers have complained about the relentless pace (driven by algorithmic decision-making) at which they are required to work. So have their US-based counterparts.

Elsewhere, large ride-hailing platforms such as Uber or food delivery platforms such as Just Eat or Deliveroo are also affecting the world of work. These organizations exert a growing influence on the lives of ‘gig workers’ as well as small business owners such as restaurateurs. Black people are twice as likely as their white counterparts to be on zero-hour contracts so Black workers are disproportionately impacted by this influence. This has knock-on effects. For example, precarious employment has been hypothesized as one of the reasons Black and other ethnic minority communities have been so disproportionately affected by Covid-19.

This is one of the reasons why it’s so important that we have access to data that will help us understand the impact of these technologies. It would also help us figure out what needs to be done to address it. Unfortunately, this data isn’t always collected as comprehensively as it needs to be; in other cases, data is collected in opaque ways and put to malicious and punitive uses e.g. DWP’s surveillance and data gathering about people receiving benefits.

We know that the plural of anecdote isn’t data but we are collating resources e.g. reports and articles, which capture the impact of data and technology on Black workers and business owners in the UK, here. Do let us know of other resources we can add to this open library.

What should we do?

Here are some things it is important to do:

  • Keep developing our collective understanding and concerns about how data and technology are used in the workplace and how these things play out in our own lives and communities
  • Stay informed about how data and technology are being developed and deployed
  • Join networks that can hold organisations to account such as workplace unions and the Trade Union Council.
  • Speak to local MPs about concerns
  • Always consider who else should be included in this discussion, but might be forgotten?

Key Terms

Add a term: include the definition here. If it’s been added to the glossary, a link will automatically appear

Technology: digital tools and systems (sometimes further enabled by data and machine learning) capable of delivering or supporting specific tasks.

Algorithms: a list of rules to follow in order to solve a problem. (See this great presentation from Edafe).

Artificial Intelligence (AI): A catch all phrase which can be misleadingly used. It covers everything from the aspirational (and currently unachieved) idea of a machine capable of general intelligence and true learning e.g. RoboCop — through to what is often called narrow AI where machines are very good at a single task, like playing chess.

Machine Learning: a branch of (narrow) AI where computer algorithms discover patterns within data and use them to build models that it applies to new data that it is presented with. Accessible guide here

Data Science: A subject/field of practice which transforms data into information, most commonly, by using machine learning techniques. Accessible guide here