• Post published:

Recommendations: how to support rather than extract from marginalised communities

You’re a funder or research organisation working with a marginalised community. You have good intentions. How can you make sure you support and don’t extract, from marginalised communities?

Between December 2020 and May 2021, we interviewed participants, convened roundtables, and ran events with and for practitioners, technologists, academics, and community leaders working with Black communities. Our aim was simple: develop an understanding of how to make data and technology have a more positive impact on the lives of Black people in the UK. Along the way, we asked: how do we share what we’ve learned so that other marginalised communities can benefit?

By the end of our work, we’d learned lessons about making interactions more holistically positive for everyone involved. We’ve set out three lessons and recommendations that we think are most relevant to funders and research organisations.

To discover broader lessons from our exploration, we shared ‘Lessons from our exploration: How data & technology impacts UK Black communities’.

What’s a marginalised community?

Marginalised communities are groups of people excluded from full participation in mainstream life. This means they don’t have full and equal access to the social, economic, educational, or cultural opportunities their societies have to offer. A community might be marginalised due to one or more factors such as their race, how they identify their gender, who they love, their age, physical ability, language, if they’ve been to prison, are working class, or are immigrants. It’s worth noting that people from marginalised communities don’t have a monolithic identity; they can identify as white, Asian, disabled, LGBT+ or a combination of these and a number of other identities.

Lesson 1 — People & Power Dynamics

We believe that understanding and addressing the impact of data and data-centric digital technologies is a long-term endeavour. And so, we recognise the need for strong networks and not just specialists and superstars.

What does this mean in practice?

1. Connect people in ways that work for them:

We found that participants at our events were most responsive when engaging with others with similar experiences, expertise, and values. These sorts of engagements led to the creation of relationships beyond the initial event.

Connecting people means not simply seeking out the most visible, vocal people . They may claim to speak for, or convene Black communities but might simply be interested in furthering their own platforms.

Connecting people effectively also means using your platform and power to reduce the burden of continuously being researched on topics that are already well known. It can sometimes seem like marginalised communities are involved in an endless conveyor belt of research projects without the corresponding actions or change.

2. Make the interactions relevant to those involved:

Experts and specialists play an essential role in helping participants see the links between their lived experience and the bigger picture. We found that stories were the best vehicle for achieving this.

Empirical data tied to real human stories — taken from popular culture or UK-based news stories — are compelling. Stories are even more effective when shared by people with relevant or similar experiences.

3. Preempt and address the knowledge gaps:

We were eager to give every one room to share at our roundtables. We recognised that if the knowledge gap within the group was too pronounced, it could discourage participation: exchanging thoughts, ideas, and relevant experiences.

To resolve this, we made sure everyone had a baseline of knowledge by preparing and distributing primers on the topics discussed ahead of every roundtable: education, crime & justice, health and employment & enterprise.

Lesson 2 — Equitable Funding

What’s the best way to understand the impact of data and technology on the lives of any group of people? Track the impact within the context of their daily lives over time. The impact of technological change can take a while to manifest. Grassroot organisations embedded in community life are best placed to do this vital tracking work — and do it in a profoundly contextual way. However, tracking is time-consuming and labour-intensive work, usually peripheral to the core mission of these organisations.

We learned that few grassroots organisations are funded to continuously monitor the impact of data and technology on their communities. This is despite the huge role technological changes are having on our society. We know that this evidence is needed to understand technology’s growing impact. Empirical tracking of trends and developments needs funding to flourish.

We believe this funding must be available to track developments and trends in the data and technology space. We also believe this funding must go to organisations working within and with marginalised communities, not only to those outside it (for example think tanks and research organisations).

How can you make funding more equitable when working with marginalised communities?

1. Fund organisations within communities to do data and tech research and provide interventions:

This helps build and keep skills and knowledge within marginalised communities and the organisations that work directly with them. Retention has two positive impacts: it directly contributes to/reduces the representation problem, and it discourages extractive practices that don’t centre the community or prioritise equitable enrichment.

2. Pay people for their time:

Marginalised communities are more likely to be financially pressured, working-class, or otherwise economically disadvantaged. Asking people to volunteer limits the pool of people who can participate, leading to a similar problem we touched on in lesson one — research conducted on the most visible, vocal, and least pressured members of marginalised communities.

3. Fund community organisers:

Keeping track of developments and trends in the data and technology space is labour- and time-consuming, so it needs proper funding. We believe it pays off in reduced duplication of effort for researchers and more robust networks within and between marginalised communities.

4. Fund core infrastructure:

Data and technology research requires community researchers to have access to IT and the internet; to have a suitable working environment; to have an appropriate living environments. Funding needs to contribute towards core costs, not just the cost of running a project and ignoring the cost of the infrastructure that research relies on.

The change we want to see is data and digital technologies that enhance Black lives (and indeed the lives of all in marginalised communities). Equitable funding helps achieve this.

Lesson 3 — Data About Us, For Us

We learned the importance of thoughtfully ensuring equitable access to data: from raw data produced as part of work done in marginalised communities to the final products of work done with marginalised communities.

Pervasive data collection is becoming the norm, but how data is collected and used isn’t equitably shared. Lack of skills and access to data directly affects the ability of marginalised communities to advocate using data. It also means that the ‘shape’ of the data reflects the priorities of those collecting it.

Very often, data about marginalised communities isn’t available for them.

Just as marginalised communities can be excluded from the design of research and the knowledge creation process, they are often denied access to the underlying data that has been collected about them. This is extraction in practice. We heard frequent stories of researchers putting out calls for Black participants to attend their workshops or seeking the help of community leaders to convene data-gathering workshops, and then failing to share the curated data or other work output with them. At most, conscientious researchers share a copy of the final report.

Why does this matter? The focus of a finished report will reflect the priorities of the funder or of the research and not necessarily those of the community the work is based on. Sharing the data (and models) provides a tangible asset that grassroots organisations and communities can use to inform other projects and initiatives. And to use that data, they’ll need skills as well as capacity. “Data about us, for us” is more than just access to data; it’s about co-developing research with communities and ensuring the critical skills to get the most out of data.

The benefits of “data about us, for us” don’’t end there — as more quality data grows in a community, so does its overall value. Deep, quality data provides a fuller and more comprehensive picture of changes within the community. It offers a sound basis to take action and support sustainable, long-term change.

While the mere existence of data doesn’t guarantee change, its absence is often cited as reason for inaction. By sharing data and related assets with grassroots organisations, funders can support communities becoming curators of their own data.

How can you help communities to retain and sustain data, knowledge, and skills?

1. Reduce pervasive data collection

Encourage organisations to take safe, ethical, and user-centred approaches to data collection. Where data exists, encourage reuse of what’s already collected.

2. Mandate data sharing

When the Gates Foundation first mandated open licensing of data and materials they funded, it was a game-changer. Funders can make a big difference to the availability of data that is safe to share by mandating safe data sharing, having clear policies about licensing, and ensuring policies are put into practice.

3. Fund grassroots data collection

Engage organisations working with marginalised communities to collect more of this data themselves. Doing so improves the skills and knowledge of using data within marginalised communities. Alongside strong networks, it reduces repetitive and duplicated data collection, which overburdens communities. An excellent example is Account Hackney, a youth-led social action project based in Hackney, London.

In Summary?

Through our work with Black communities, it became clear to us that while there is value in demanding greater transparency and access to data collected about communities, there are other ways of ensuring that “data about us is also for us”. The three ways we’ve listed are a good starting point for organisations with no cohesive policies to start preventing extractive data practices.

Extractive practices do not build communities. Marginalised communities are frequently observed and researched; however, the benefits do not trickle down to the communities themselves. Currently, the fiscal focus of research funding is often organisations without any ties to or investment in the marginalised communities being researched. Our recommendations seek to shift power and funding, increase equity and re-centre power in marginalised communities. We believe this is the best route to the lasting and sustainable change that most funders genuinely want to see.